Something To Look Forward To

Over the last several months, it’s sadly come to my attention that there’s a vital part of The Mockingjay story that keeps getting looked over, or forgotten from the fan perspective. The music, or most importantly, The Hanging Tree.

I’m no music expert, But I’m a music the_hanging_tree_by_alys23-d4temogfan– I listen to all sorts of genres, but one genre I listen to in particular has a thread that weaves its way throughout The Hunger Games series, traditional American folk music, or Americana. Music that originated in Scotland, England, and Ireland, but immigrated along with the influx of immigrants from the British isles in the 18th century, and earlier to North America. The Hanging Tree however is an original song, penned by Suzanne Collins, but in the style of the folk music that amazingly was preserved for more than 200 years in the Appalachian mountains, purely by the isolated nature of the location, and its people.

The Appalachian mountains is where District 12 is located though, so that means that if and when we hear The Hanging Tree sung on-screen in Mockingjay Part 1, or 2, it may sound like this, rather than the multitudes of fan-made versions that from my experience are decent, but rarely take traditional folk rhythms, and lyrical cadences into account.

The Hanging Tree is a haunting song, a dirge, like “O Death”, which was brought back to the worlds attention when it was used in the Cohen Brother’s film O Brother Where Art Thou in 2000. That was 15 years ago though, and nothing like the Oscar winning O Brother Where Art Thou soundtrack has come about since. And, get this– T Bone Burnett the producer of The Hunger Games soundtrack, produced O Brother. The Hunger Games soundtrack was good, I’ll give it that– I like to pretend however that it was better, and that certain pop singers had not recorded certain songs that were written and performed by a certain other Oscar winning singer/ song writer originally. The Hanging Tree, like the song I’ve feigned to above, will probably get the same treatment– erm, how do I say this nicely–? Jennifer Lawrence is not the best singer, in fact in the film The House at the End of the Street where she played a teenager with musical proclivities– they dubbed her voice out during the portions of the film where she was required to sing. So, I think for The Hanging Tree, we’re going to get someone else’ pipes being heard by that placid lake. That is unless Jen has become an amazing singer since House at the End of the Street was filmed.

Until then, if you’re at all interested in hearing and seeing more American traditional folk music performed on film, I recommend the 2000 film Songcatcher, O Brother Where Art There of course, Cold Mountain, and Inside Llewyin Davis.

Them There Eyes

Advertisements

4 comments

  1. The Hanging Tree will be a major beat in Mockingjay Part I, I can’t wait to see what Francis and James Newton Howard came up with.

  2. I think in general, the Appalachia aspect of Twelve, barring the coal mining, is glossed over by much of the fandom; that would include dialect and the style of arts.
    It could be various reasons for that, from just basic lack of knowledge to a negative preconception of that region.

    In any case, agreed that if it comes to being sung, whether it’s a voiceover or not, it should be infused with that same Americana/folk/whatever-you-want to-call-it vibe and not just be whatever’s “in” at the time.

  3. I agree, I’m hoping for a folksy sounding “Hanging Tree.” I would love anything that was similar sounding to the Llewyn Davis soundtrack (great soundtrack, ok movie). I’ve been wanting Mumford & Sons or at least Marcus Mumford (who helped with the Llewyn Davis soundtrack) to be involved with these movies forever, though I don’t know that that will ever happen.

    Even an old Mumford song would work, some of them seem like they were inspired by these stories already, especially Mockingjay. I can’t hear “Ghosts That We Knew” and not think of Katniss visiting D12 after the bombing or “Reminder” without thinking of the conversation between Gale & Katniss after (SPOILER ALERT) Prim’s death or “Hopeless Wanderer” reminds me of Katniss helping Peeta recover from his Hijacked state… really so many of their songs remind me of the series. Anyway, tangent, hoping for more folksy music in the movies!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s